There's a common saying that the sub holds all the power in a BDSM dynamic. I'm sure you've heard it. I've heard it. It's all over Reddit and FetLife and Tumblr and Twitter (I refuse to call it X) and Bluesky…
It's kind of true, but not really. It leaves out a lot of really important points and a lot of nuance, because it's a sound bite and not a real rule. Real rules require education, discussion, communication, and understanding.
That sound bite comes off as a blanket statement.
It's a well-meaning statement, and it's likely a correction to the idea that subs are powerless before the Dom. I think that it's there to give new submissives, or people dabbling in the space, the ability to feel like they're not giving up all of their agency the moment they talk to somebody. And that's a good thing.
It likely also helps by bolstering newcomers' confidence and allowing them to spot abusers who would take away their agency before they would give it up willingly.
But the blanket sound bite version is an overcorrection that I feel leaves the dominant partner out in the cold.
Some people say that the sub draws the lines and the Dom colors inside them, but that's an oversimplification as well. The sub may draw the lines in terms of hard limits, but anything that's a soft limit is a sketch, still requiring ink from the Dom. So let's talk real stuff.
Contrary to what puritanical societies would have you believe, the dominant is not an abuser. And an abuser is not a dominant.
There are abusers who don't deserve the title of dominant. Submissives have a responsibility in this process and partnership. They should, at least, even when new, have an idea of what appeals to them about this. They should be willing to sit down and talk with a dominant and say, these are the things that I think I like, these are the things that I'd be willing to explore, these are the things that disgust or terrify me.
A good dominant or a kink educator will sit down and begin a roadmap for exploration and education.
The idea that the submissive holds all the power is the exact same fallacy as saying the customer is always right. The customer's only right in knowing what they need and want, but they may not know what's in stock, what's available, or what's new.
I'm not saying that a submissive doesn't have the power to withdraw consent; of course they do. But granting consent is not power. It's allowing others to use their power.
There needs to be understanding and respect for the role of the dominant in all of this.
Dominants have limits and safewords too. Dominants have the right to call an end to a scene. There may be submissives who engaged or indulged in substances, and then the dominant doesn't feel safe playing with them. There may be submissives in such a state that they can't safeword. There may be dominants who are uncomfortable with things that the sub wants to do.
The submissive is granting power and consent, yes, but so is the dominant. Let's not forget that this is two halves of the same coin, and both sides need each other. Both sides have limits, both sides have desires, both sides have aftercare needs.
Painting the submissive as the only one with the power teaches new submissives that the dominant is a kink dispenser, with the idea that you put some sort of FetLife token into them and out pops a paddle or a cane.
In many cases the submissive is actually looking to relieve themselves of agency, perhaps for the purpose of release, and there needs to be recognition that in doing that they're passing personal responsibility on to somebody else, and that's a heavy weight for a dominant to carry.
Dominants run the risk of worrying if they've gone too far. They hold the responsibility of keeping somebody else safe in their arms.
One of the major problems that I see with the statement is that it's specific to within a scene, but it's being applied as though it were about rules and equality as people. Dominants and submissives are equals as people; they just have different roles in the scene.
The submissive's needs come before the dominant's needs, but the dominant's wants come before the submissive's wants during play. After all, if the submissive's wants come before the dominant's wants, what's the point of submitting?
The dominant role is so much more than just spanking or beating. The dominant has to watch for changes in the color of the skin that may display ligature problems. They have to watch the clock, they have to check on the submissive's breathing, they have to check in on the submissive, they have to ensure that they don't go too far, and they have to ensure that the sub doesn't go too far.
And if something does go wrong, they have to be able to fix it and be willing to carry the burden.
And while we're on it, let's not forget that although we hear about subspace and sub drop, Dom space and Dom drop are real things as well.
Saying that the submissive holds all of the control ignores nuance. It ignores the fact that dominance is a gift too. It ignores the idea that this is a dance between people, not rules. Both parties are giving something the other needs, and that should never be forgotten.